Why Most Writing Advice Fails Christian Writers

How to Find Balance Between Digital Strategy and Spiritual Authenticity

I stared at my article draft. The cursor blinked accusingly.

I'd followed all the expert advice for writing online:

Short paragraphs. Compelling hook. Clear value proposition in the first three lines.

Everything had been optimized for the modern reader and their notoriously short attention spans.

And yet… something felt hollow.

The words were polished and formatted perfectly.

But I realized that my focus on technique was creating an invisible barrier between my heart and my readers.

Here I was, trying to share what I considered to be deep spiritual truths, but packaging them like a marketing email.

Now, don't get me wrong—the advice about writing for digital platforms isn't wrong. Our readers do skim. They are overwhelmed with content. They do need to quickly understand what's in it for them. These are realities of modern communication.

But for Christian writers, there's a tension here that most writing advice never addresses.

How do we navigate the space between technical excellence and actual, authentic vulnerability?

What I've discovered is that there's a way to bridge this gap—but it requires us to challenge some fundamental assumptions about what makes writing effective.

The Surface Problem

In truth, modern writing advice exists for good reasons.

We live in an age where words compete with endless distractions, where readers make split-second decisions about what deserves their attention.

The experts aren't wrong when they tell us to:

• Hook readers in the first few seconds

• Break up walls of text into digestible chunks

• Write headlines that clearly communicate value

• Structure content for easy scanning

• Optimize for different platforms and formats

This is all sound advice, and there's nothing inherently un-Christian about being strategic or skillful in our communication. After all, even the biblical writers used different literary devices and styles to effectively reach their audiences.

But when we focus solely on these “technical” aspects, I’ve realized that something vital gets lost in translation.

Really, how do you optimize a story of God's faithfulness in your darkest moment for SEO? What's the perfect "value proposition" for sharing your spiritual struggles or praises?

The problem isn't with the writing advice itself. The problem is that it's built on assumptions that don't fully align with our calling as Christian writers.

The Deeper Reality

Much of traditional writing wisdom assumes that content comes primarily from research and expertise.

While knowledge certainly matters, Christian writers draw from a deeper well: our ongoing relationship with God and the lived experience of walking with Christ.

The same writing advice often treats writing as mere communication.

But Christian writing serves a dual purpose—it's both communication and communion. It's a sacred space where writer, reader, and God meet.

Our Unique Position

And this is where many Christian writers, myself included, get stuck.

We see these two realms—the spiritual and the technical, the divine and the digital— and sometimes we feel like we have to choose between them. We find ourselves wrestling with false dichotomies:

• Skimmability OR spiritual depth?

• Improving our skill OR relying on divine inspiration?

• Growing our platform OR maintaining humility?

But these aren't actually choices we need to make. The real challenge, and opportunity, is learning to integrate both realms in a way that honors God and serves our readers.

The goal isn't to choose between being skilled and being spiritual. It's learning to:

Let technical excellence serve spiritual purpose. Those writing techniques aren't barriers to authenticity, but tools for delivering truth more effectively. When we improve them from a place of spiritual groundedness, they serve to amplify rather than diminish His message.

Write from identity rather than for validation. This changes everything. Instead of using techniques to prove our worth as writers, we use them to express who we already are in Christ. The pressure lifts. The striving ceases. We're free to be both strategic and authentic.

Build influence through surrender. Ironically, I believe that the more we surrender our platform to God, the more effectively we can steward its growth. When metrics inform but don't define us, we can use them wisely without being owned by them.

Master digital tools without being mastered by them. Modern platforms are a mission field. We can learn their languages and rhythms while staying rooted in a deeper reality—one might even say “wise as serpents and innocent as doves.”

The Way Forward

So what does this look like in practice? How do we actually write in a way that bridges the gap between effectiveness in the modern digital landscape and spiritual authenticity?

It starts with a fundamental shift in how we approach our writing. Instead of beginning with techniques and trying to add spiritual depth, we start with our identity in Christ and let everything flow from there.

This means that your writing time becomes sacred space. Before you open your laptop or grab your notebook, pause to remember whose you are. Your worth isn't hanging on your next piece. Your identity isn't tied to your metrics. You're a child of God who writes, not a writer trying to please God.

This doesn't ignore the realities of writing in the digital age.

It redeems them.

It turns the very things that often cause anxiety—platform building, content strategy, audience growth—into opportunities for deeper dependence on God.

---

The world doesn't need more Christian writers who have mastered “online writing.”

It needs writers who have learned to let their craft serve a deeper purpose. Writers who understand that true impact flows not from perfectly optimized content but from lives overflowing with God's presence.

If you've been feeling the tension between modern writing advice and your calling as a Christian writer, know this: You don't have to choose.

There's a way to write that honors both your craft and your calling, that reaches modern readers without compromising your soul.